The Cost of Silence
About Child Abuse in ISKCON Hare Krishna Gurukul Boarding Schools
By Madhudvisa das
The Cost of Silence — Children of the Hare Krishnas is a new film produced by Sanaka dasa who was raised in ISKCON gurukuls in Italy and in India. As a child he witnessed different forms of abuse on a regular basis. Sanaka has dedicated the film to the generations of Hare Krishna children whose suffering has been ignored and silenced. The Cost of Silence was released on the auspicious day of Sri Nrsimha Caturdasi, May 20 2016.
“For you child-worship is more important than Deity worship. If you can not spend time with him then stop the duties of pujari.
“These children are given to us by Krishna, they are Vaisnavas and we must be very careful to protect them.
“Try as far as possible to discipline them with love and affection.” (Srila Prabhupada in 1972 letters to Aniruddha)
In ancient India children were placed in the care of an enlightened teacher, the guru, who was qualified to look after the material, emotional and spiritual development of his students. These schools were known as gurukulas.
Nowadays many believe that child abuse is a dark chapter in the distant past of the Hare Krishna movement and that now there is an effective child protection system in place. Although some progress has been made over the years the current policies are still inadequate.
At present ISKCON does not offer any form of support, assistance or counsel to child abuse victims.
In the Hare Krishna movement political influence and spiritual authority often rest with the same people. This monopoly has created conflicts of interest that have frequently led to a misuse of power. Generally the need to be respectful to these leaders and the sentiments of their followers has been given priority over the need to protect children. This in turn has fostered an environment where accountability has been problematic and children have suffered.
The GBC controls the child protection office. Effectively we have a scenario where prosecution, judge and jury are all working for the same team. The current system has little room for independent revision, appeals or scrutiny and consequently credibility.
ISKCON MAYAPUR GURUKUL
“My name is Prem Sarga dasa and I came to Mayapur gurukul in 1987, December, and I stayed until 1993. During that time which was around five years Bhaktividya Purna Swami (Alan Ross Wexler) was the principal of the school. There were several times when Maharaja beat physically the gurukul children during my time. Maharaja was famous for carrying a bamboo stick, you could bend it and it looked like a whip. Maharaja gathered everybody at the Hanuman house and older and younger boys were witnessing this punishment. He requested the three boys [who were being punished] to bend over and hold the back of their ankles and Maharaja used his bamboo stick as a whip to hit each boy three times. The mark left by the whip was very bad, it took days to fade away. One of them had some blood coming out. Everybody was completely flabbergasted to see Maharaja’s action.
“Regarding the sexual abuse to children I remember clearly that in many occasions Maharaja was approached by the students mentioning that they were being molested by older boys and Maharaja just couldn’t do anything about it or he would question the boy. In one particular case I recall he questioned the boy that, “How do you know you have been molested?” Of course the reply was not very clear. So basically Maharaja did not do anything about it, did no accept it and did not file the case.”
Dhira Govinda dasa, at the time the director of the ISKCON Child Protection Office (CPO), recalls and interview he had with Bhaktividya Purna Swami about the child abuse problems at his Mayapur gurukul. “I asked him, ‘Bhaktividya Purna Swami your saying that there’s ten boys, the report indicates definitely more than thirty. You’re saying it was consensual and of the same age except maybe in one case but this report describes rampant force and violence from older to younger and multi-geneational sexual deviance.’ Of course the report recommended that Bhaktividya Purna Swami leave and so he left. But when we follow the history six weeks later he’s back in the same position after the investigators went away.
“He’s not aware of half a percent of what happened, how children were brutalized under his supervision, at the same time he has a signed letter from 1991 saying that he read the report closely. If you read the report closely it’s not something that you will forget in this lifetime.”
ISKCON’s Child Protection Office issued a ruling on Bhaktividya Purna Swami on September 20, 2000. “Bhaktividya Purna Maharaja won’t serve in any capacity that is directly connected with children until January 1, 2002. After that he may serve in a non-managerial and non-administrative capacity connected with children if the ISKCON Education Ministry agrees that he may do so. Bhaktividya Purna Maharaja may not at any time assume a managerial or administrative role in ISKCON, and especially not in connection with children.”
Today (2016) Bhaktividya Purna Swami is still running a gurukula in Mayapur, still working with children in ISKCON. The current management of Bhaktividya Purna Maharaja’s school is made up almost exclusively of his disciples. So even though Maharaja may not look after the day to day management of his school, effectively this arrangement gives him far more managerial influence than he should be allowed.
In a in 2011 letter Champakalata Mataja, the ISKCON Child Protection Office director, affirmed that the ISKCON ministry of education encouraged Bhaktividya Purna Maharaja to resume his involvement with children…..
Sri Radhe, a disciple of Indradyumna Swami was appointed as the principal of Bhaktividya Purna Maharaja’s girls gurukul in Mayapur, Sri Anasuya Vidyamanadala (education for girls).
When Sri Radhe became the principle of the girls gurukul in Mayapur she was 19 years of age. She had no teaching qualifications or experience.
The ISKCON Child Protection Office has carried out two investigations on Bhaktividya Purna Maharaja’s girls gurukul. The first was in 2007 and the second in 2015. The 2007 documents state that Bhaktividya Purna Maharaja would pump water for the young girls in his school while they were bathing naked in front of him and then he would massage them while they were semi-naked, wearing their underwear only. The 2015 report reads: “Based on the above statements there should be zero tolerance of her (Sri Radhe) ever teaching or caring for children ever again effective immediately.”
Both the 2007 and the 2015 ISKCON Child Protection Office documents state that Sri Radhe and Bhaktividya Purna Maharaja regularly spent extended amounts of time alone. The report says that students have walked in on them behaving in a frivolous manner and indecently dressed. On the seventh of May 2015 the ISKCON Child Protection Office placed a lifelong ban on Sri Radhe from holding any positions related to children. Bhaktividya Purna Maharaja’s girls gurukul has now been closed.
For years there have been rumors that both Sri Radhe and Bhaktividya Purna Maharaja were mistreating the girls. The involvement of a sannyasi in the education of young girls should have been regarded as unacceptable even if Bhaktividya Purna Maharaja did not already have a history of child abuse. The ISKCON Child Protection Office granted an appeal to Sri Radhe despite the fact that she did not meet the requirements to be eligible for one. The appeal panel removed the lifelong ban on Sri Radhe caring for and teaching children in ISKCON.
Sanaka dasa grew up in ISKCON gurukuls and child protection was been a concern for most of his life. He made several attempts to request a review of Bhaktividya Purna Maharaja’s circumstances following ISKCON’s appropriate channels without any success. For this reason he felt that disrupting one of his lectures at Bhaktivedanta Manor near London was the only option left. Bhaktividya Purna Maharaja’s only response to this challenge was “It’s not true…” The audience was more shocked by Sanaka dasa’s disruption than to discover that a known child abuser is involved in the education of children in ISKCON.
ISKCON VRINDAVAN GURUKUL
Dhanurdhara Swami was the principal of the Vrindavan gurukula for many years. The ISKCON Child Protection Office found him personally responsible for physical and physiological abuse and neglect of children placed under his care. Even though many ISKCON leaders were aware of the extensive nature of the abuse Dhanurdhara Swami received much support and remained in his position for more than a decade. Even today Dhanurdhara Swami is a regular speaker at the Bhakti Center, Radhanatha Swami’s temple in New York City. This is in contempt of the ISKCON Child Protection Office sanctions placed on Dhanurdhara Swami.
The GBC body publicly apologized to Dhanurdhara Swami: “The GBC body is sorry for the difficulties you and your disciples, followers and friends must have experienced because of these long and cumbersome procedures. We could have done much better, and we sincerely apologize.”
It’s like if a government apologized to a child abuser for the troubles and inconvenience he experienced while being adjudicated for his crimes. In 1995 Gauri dasa (George Kilmurry) was the head teacher in the Vrindavan gurukula. After an incident where he had beaten three children a number of former students wrote to the GBC and were able to obtain a ban on the use of corporal punishment in the school. Then a teacher, Braja Bihari dasa (Brian Bloch), wrote a letter to the GBC petitioning them for the reinstatement of corporal punishment:
“Please understand clearly the two concerns (needs) of the Vrindavan gurukula school: 1) Corporal punishment must be reinstated, 2) Gauri dasa must be allowed to administer corporal punishment. He will use corporal punishment only in the presence of the ashram teacher, and will not use it at all on the boys in his ashram (the older boys). That is what we want. It’s reasonable.”
In response to this request from Braja Bihari the GBC did reinstate corporal punishment at the ISKCON Vrindavan gurukula.
When the case of Gauri dasa came up for review in 2006 three GBC members wrote letters of support: Siva Rama Swami, Sesa dasa and Progosa dasa. As a result the GBC have now appointed Gauri dasa as the managing director of Bhaktivedanta Manor in the UK. This is one of the biggest temples in ISKCON and the position carries one of the highest salaries paid in ISKCON.
In 2010 Gopal Krishna Maharaja took over the management of the Vrindavan gurukul, he claims: ”The Bhaktivedanta Gurukul and International School is a school with a difference…”
Gopal Krishna Maharaja appointed Lila Purushottam (Laxmidhar Behera) as the new principal of the Vrindavan gurukul. As Lila Purushottam lives three hundred kilometers away from Vrindavan he needed someone to look after the day-to-day management of the school. So he appointed Radhakanat dasa as the vice-principal. He was a twenty-five year old straight from IIT Kanpur with no experience of life and no experience in dealing with children. He had been living a life of brahmacary [celibate monk] and he had no background in education or administration.
In 2011 one of the teachers in the Vrindavan gurukul reported a colleague for beating the children. The school management then asked the teacher that reported the incident to leave. Any school that operates with a policy of discouraging the reporting of incidents is bound to have big problems with child abuse.
We have many actual reports filed over the last six years of physical, sexual and emotional abuse of the children of the Vrindavan gurukul. The 2014 ISKCON Child Protection report on the Vrindavan gurukul states “Six boys in year six were sexually molested by three older bullies in there ashram (dorms). In all cases the victims were threatened not to tell anyone about these activities. This happened many times over an eight to ten month period. The victims were afraid to speak out about this. In Vrindavan unawareness of child protection principles goes right up to the GBC (Gopal Krishna Maharaj).
Any time the abuse was brought to management the order was “Please keep this in the family of ISKCON, do not let it get out.” When the matter was brought to the GBC Gopal Krishna Maharaj his reply was: “Lila Purusotoma Prabhu runs the management in Vrindavan gurukul. I as the GBC can not interfere with the regular running of the school. But you don’t worry about anything, you just continue your work of collecting money for the school…”
The mother of one of the ISKCON Vrindavan gurukul students pleads: “My child studies in the Bhaktivedanta Gurukula in Vrindavan. I have come to know that the children in the school are sexually abused. I sent my children to the Vrindavan gurukula because it is such an exceptional place. The school is supposed to teach Bhakti Bhav (love of God) in Bhakti Dharm (the most sacred place). So I was very shocked to discover that sexual abuse is going on. This has happened to my children. Despite the fact that the management is aware of these problems, they take no action to address this problem. I request you kindly close this school because this sexual abuse will destroy the future of our children.”
Anita Khetarpal (M.A. English) served as the academic director for the ISKCON Vrindavan gurukul for seven years. During this time she observed the problem of child abuse in the school and tried to the best of her ability through the official channels to stop the abuse of the children. She explains one situation with Devasish, who had a long history of child sexual abuse and who was therefore forbidden to enter the gurukul because of his past crimes. “I saw that Devasish was hovering around the school too close. I was alarmed. I also know that he was passing by the security and that he was entering the school. When I mentioned to Lila Purusotama [the principal] that, ‘Devasish has a history of child abuse and why is he being allowed into the school?’ So his reply was, ‘Mataji it is none of your business, we know what we are doing and he is a very well connected person, he is known to a lot of very, very big people, he is very useful to us and this child abuse is only Western propaganda to malign his name. There is no truth to all this.’ And then in February of 2015 I get a call from a parent of one of my ex-students telling me that national television is reporting the children of Bhaktivedanta Gurukul and International School Vrindavan have been sexually molested and Devasish has been arrested and I was completely devastated because in front of me were all my worst nightmares. I could see it was actually happening. What I warned these people of and they never heard me today was a reality.”
RADHANATHA SWAMI & KIRTANANANDA SWAMI &
NEW VRINDAVAN
Radhanatha Swami (Richard Slavin) is a GBC, a guru and a leading figure in the Hare Krishna Movement. He says, “On a worldwide basis, the leaders of ISKCON are really coming together and connecting throughout the year on issues that the GBC themselves have felt are the most important, crucial issues for the present and future of Prabhuapda’s society.” For this he gets a round of applause from the GBC members. Of course they do not discuss child abuse…
Kirtanananda Swami (Keith Ham) is one of the former leaders of the Hare Krishna movement (now deceased). Kirtanananda Swami was a convicted criminal. The US Federal Court charged him with conspiracy to murder two devotees and the ISKCON Child Protection Office found him guilty of child sexual abuse. It was charged that Kirtanananda ordered the murder of these devotees because they had threatened to expose his child abuse activities. Now we see leading ISKCON devotees including Radhanatha Swami and Gopal Krishna Maharaja paying their respects by bowing down at the grave of Kirtanananda. This is offensive to his victims, it is also a statement on the value they place on child protection.
In the 1980′s Sri Galim (Garry Gardner) was the principal of the Gurukula in New Vrindavan. At one point the members of the community became aware that he had sexually abused several children in the school and they asked him to leave. It is claimed that Radhanatha Swami opposed the decision to ban this man from the community. The following is a statement from a New Vrindavan gurukul student: “Sri Galim has a charismatic personality and is quite learned in scriptures and makes all external appearances of being a first-class Vaishnava. That made him popular among many first generation devotees. Sri Galim and Radhanatha Swami have been friends since the early 1970′s. Radhanatha Swami did oppose excommunicating Sri Galim.”
There is so much more…
Please watch The Cost of Silence — Children of the Hare Krishnas and consider how we can save the children of ISKCON.
Please also see:
Vrindavana Gurukula Children Abused
ISKCON Children Expose Child Abusers Part1
ISKCON Children Expose Child Abusers Part2
ISKCON Child Abuse Part3
ISKCON Child Abuse Part4
pamho agtACBSP,the most amazing thing is that some of these demons are still alive like that monkey of bhavananda etc… but nobody do nothing to sent all these nasty and horrible demons straight to yamaraj therefore the cost of silence is still going on agtSP ys haribol
Bhakti Vikash asks the question “What is child abuse?”
”Child abuse is putting your child in a situation where they are forced to worship FISKCON ‘bogus gooroo monkeys’ as bona-fide representatives of Srila Prabhupada in the form of diksa guru (which they are not).
Child abuse is indoctrinating your children to honour and worship those who murdered Srila Prabhupada……… COLD, CALCULATED MURDERERS, THIEVES, CHILD MOLESTERS, LIARS, DECEIVERS, AND REPROBATES.”